The biggest problem with this representation of our diet is that it WAY over-emphasis the very food group that (1) destabilises our insulin production (which in turn drives fat storage and other unpleasant stuff), and (2) provides the least nutrition. The foods in all the other groups provide plenty more nutrients in our diet (provided you are eating them as close to a natural source as possible - and no, industrial vegetable/seed/nut oils are NOT in a natural form). Grains are empty calories devoid of nutrition.
Let's back the Studebaker back over to 1959 and let's see what the representation was of our diet at that time.
Yes folks, it's the diet cartwheel! Oh, I love this. What a great representation. The best thing about this is that it doesn't overemphasise any one food group. All are equal in importance for a balanced diet.
The pyramid is clearly not balanced. In my high carb/low fat days, I religiously followed the pyramid. I checked nutrition labels of food I was buying to make sure I was not eating too much fat and that the grains were whole grain. Well, that all lead to the unpleasant side-effects I was experiencing. As soon as I got off the grains, especially wheat, and upped my protein and (natural) fat intake, I started feeling like superman.
We can learn a lot from the way we used to eat, before the "experts" got involved and screwed it up.
Hi Schmaltz,
ReplyDeleteGreat blog! I found it via a reference in the comments on Dr. Mike Eades's Protein Power blog -- the schmaltz and soy post: http://www.proteinpower.com/drmike/good-eating/schmaltz-and-soy/
Coincidentally, minutes before I found your "cartwheel" post, my husband had sent me a link to this article about an exhibit at the UW-Madison tracing "food fads" through the 20th century.
http://host.madison.com/ct/news/local/health_med_fit/article_6d290708-39a4-11df-be28-001cc4c002e0.html
A similar wheel is the opening image in the related video. Note how silly they imply its advice to be.
http://host.madison.com/news/video/vmix_fc8155aa-39a3-11df-ad2c-001cc4c002e0.html
Hi Vesna,
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment and the link. I was a bit confused, as I actually commented on that post, but used my real name and not my Shmaltz "pseudonym", so I was wondering how you found me. I then saw the link by another commenter. Thanks for stopping by.
Indeed the images are very similar, but the concept is identical - all food groups are equal, with no overemphasis on carbs/grains.
I like their comment in the video: "the more things change, the more they stay the same". Very true.